Confronting Idols: Notes from a Conference

Tim Keller is likely the best writer and speaker on the subject of idolatry for our day. Keller is a pastor of Redeemer Church in NYC, and has heavily influenced myself (Ryan, Lead Pastor of imago dei) and many other pastors within the Acts29 network. Keller offers help in understanding our addiction to idols and the substitutes that we all chose instead of Christ. Below are some notes from a conference that he spoke at. The original article can be found at the resurgence website. 

Confront Idols

You can't preach the gospel effectively if you don't challenge idols. Paul always challenged people's idols in his preaching. In Acts 17, Paul went to the Agora, the marketplace, which is where the idols of that culture were formed. In our culture, the marketplace is not shops and busy streets, because that's no longer where culture is formed. For us, challenging idols in the marketplace means going to Hollywood, Harvard, and the New York Times—the places where ideas and beliefs are shaped. Every culture, gender, class, city, field of work, etc., has its own idols. Idolatry is anything I look at and say, "If I have that, my life has value." Anything that is so central to your life that you feel you can't live without it is an idol. Idolatry is making a good thing an ultimate thing. Because Paul saw idols everywhere, he was a really effective preacher. Like Paul, we need to discern, expose, and destroy idols in order to preach the gospel.

3 Kinds of Idols You Have to Expose to Preach the Gospel:

1. Personal Idols
2. Religious Idols
3. Cultural Idols

 

#1 Personal Idols

• Money can be an idol, especially in the business world. Everyone recognizes this as the idol of Wall Street. (All over New York City, child sacrifice is going on. If you want to succeed, you have to sacrifice your family. If you're going to get the money and power, you must sacrifice your children. Jobs are set up that way.) How do you do your job without bowing down to it—how do you demythologize money? Only by living in the gospel.
• Romance is another idol. This is when you look to your lover or spouse for worth. Only they can make you feel valuable. You cannot lose this person. People who have a good marriage must constantly fight this idol, constantly looking to Jesus and finding their satisfaction in Jesus more than their spouse.
• Self-expression is an idol of the artistic community.
• Children can be idolized when you find your significance and meaning in your children. You know you're worth something if your children turn out well.

Unless you understand personal idols, your counseling, pastoring, and mentoring is going to be superficial. You won't really be able to help people. As Luther said, there's a reason the first of the Ten Commandments is about idolatry. You never break commandments 2-10 without first breaking number 1. You cannot understand moral failings or psychological problems without understanding idolatry. 

#2 Religious Idols

Those who worship religious idols think they are devoted to God, but they're not.

• Truth can be made an idol. Are you resting in the rightness of your doctrine rather than the work of Jesus? If so, the Bible calls you a fool. In Proverbs, "the scoffer" is a person like this. The scoffer is always sure he is right, and always disrespectful, disdainful, and mocking toward his opponents. The internet breeds scoffers, because if you're a scoffer you get more traffic to your blog.
• Gifts can be an idol. You can mistake spiritual gifts for spiritual fruit. Especially if you are successful in ministry, you can begin believing in justification by ministry: "I know I'm in God's will because my ministry is going well." Many of us in the Reformed world make an idol out of being a great preacher: "If I could just be a great preacher, then my life would have significance."
• Morality is a religious idol. It's typical for Christians to feel that God loves them and will bless them because of their moral record.

#3 Cultural Idols

Evangelicals love to talk about cultural idols. We look back at the idols of the Enlightenment: the elevation of human reason, the belief that reason/science will solve all the world's problems. Today we see the idol of individualism. We attack Western individualism, but in many traditional cultures family is an idol—so you have honor killings, women treated as property, etc. In individualistic cultures like our own, the individual is an idol. No one can tell anyone else they're wrong, no one can impose their beliefs about God on anyone else. Any ideology can be an idol: free-market economics, communism, socialism, democracy, liberalism, etc.

Confronting Idols Is Dangerous

When idols are opposed, it's dangerous. Idols are violent. Through idols, the powers and principalities control us. If you oppose them, you take your life in your hands. Paul risked his life to oppose them; he rested in Jesus, who had already given his life to defeat the principalities and powers. Jesus defeated the idols both objectively and subjectively through the cross:

• Objectively: Punishment for our adultery and reconciliation with God were fulfilled in Jesus.
• Subjectively: We remember that none of our idols can die for our sins. Our idols will always crumble under the weight of our expectations. Only by living in the power of the cross, exulting in the cross, and proclaiming the cross can we be fearless and free from the power of idols.  
• You must learn how to take the gospel to the idols. 

Don't forget you can watch the live stream of all ten Gospel Coalition plenary addresses at Christianity.com. The audio and video will be available free from The Gospel Coalition.